Posted on Wed 17 October 2018

Read Time: 3 minutes

Updated (November 24, 2018) - When Good Software gets Trapped in the “Cloud.”

Updated Comments

Please see the above for my updated comments on Notion and my mea culpa as I missed a key part of their feature set which essentially resolves all of the concerns I outline below.

One of the challenges of living in an era where software applications and their associated files are rented instead of owned is that there are moments when I find something that I really love that is completely broken.

I really like what Notion does. As a project management tool, it is an amazing piece of software. On a very basic level, it is a simplified document and project management system, but that is really under-selling its capacity. The genius of the software is in its simplicity and accessibility. I can build a rapid version of project tracking database in less than 30 minutes, add a documentation space, connect it to a Slack channel for regular project updates, and be good to go. Courtney and I have been using it for our game design project. I am tracking my dissertation work and my job hunt via the site, and it has been quite useful. I have no complaints on the use of the software. There is no denying that.

If Notion was a software package I could buy, I would already own it. Sadly, it’s not. It’s a web-based application. If I use it, I place all my critical project data into it and trust that nothing will go wrong. I trust that Notion has my best interests in mind. I trust that they have managed their security. I trust that they won’t suddenly raise prices or sell to another company with different data and privacy policies. Essentially, I would have to trust a lot. If you’ve been paying any attention to online companies these days, you know that trust is absolutely not warranted.

But wait,” I can hear you saying, “What about Slack and Github/Gitlab? Aren’t they online tools? You use them.”

I do. But my Slack data is not critical (my Discord data is even less critical). I could lose both sites tomorrow and be fine. If I were to lose my dissertation and job hunt project databases, that would be catastrophic. While Notion allows me to export data (which I do), it really isn’t usable in the exported markdown formats. My hosted git repositories, on the other hand, are all backed up locally and completely usable. I would be sorry to see Github or Gitlab die, but nothing would happen to my data. The same is true for Dropbox; although, I am in the process of migrating to Spideroak simply because I like its feature-set. I regularly backup all my critical files. Dropbox, like Spideroak, is literally a fancy version of the rsync tool for me and nothing more.

I don’t have a problem using cloud based software that allows me to control and access my data in a usable way. I do have a problem with software that demands I keep my data inside its systems to be usable. I like Notion. I love what it does, but I don’t think I will be using it much longer.

Author: Geoff Gimse

Category: technology

Tags: cloud, privacy, notion

© Geoffrey Gimse. Built using Pelican. All photos are my own. Other images used on this site are in the Public Domain and available from Openclipart, or have been purchased for use via The Noun Project.